Trains For America

More choices for better transportation

New York State high-speed rail plan stagnant

Out of the Utica Observer-Dispatch comes an article about the status of the proposed upstate New York high-speed rail plan. The original idea was to undertake a number of improvements to the tracks between NYC and Buffalo in order to reduce rail travel times and reinvigorate the upstate area. Here are some of the possible methods from the article:

Among the proposals:
* Make improvements in the next several years to fix outdated tracks and signals.

* Over the next two decades, use new technology and, in some cases, new tracks and bridges to reduce the train travel time from 2½ hours between Albany and New York City to as little as one hour.

* In the long run, reduce train travel time between western New York and Albany from about five hours and 45 minutes to as little as two hours to three hours.

* Total spending proposed over two decades could exceed $10 billion. However, the report cited numerous benefits, including a five-million gallon reduction in gasoline use by upstate drivers.

The state would have to establish a rail authority to manage such a plan, said state Sen. Tom Libous, chairman of the Senate’s Standing Committee on Transportation. And authorities across the state are under scrutiny right now, so it would be difficult to convince the state government to establish a new one, he said.

The article indicates that there is still some optimism about the project, but with fuel prices the way they are, now is not the time for the state to be sitting on its laurels.

It seems like a common pattern with state HSR plans, actually. Voters demand better passenger rail, and a grand plan is developed. Then it’s either killed off by short-sighted politicians (see: Jeb Bush and Florida) or those with a vested interest in limiting Americans’ transportation options (see: Southwest Airlines and Texas). In New York it seems to be nothing more than bureaucracy. Let’s hope that the current fuel crisis and what looks to be a probable victory for HSR in California will help bolster efforts in other states.


Filed under: Uncategorized

2 Responses

  1. giamfam says:

    Here we go again, elected officials at federal, state and local levels agreeing. WATCH YOUR WALLETS!

    Now they want to spend $8 Billion on high speed rail between Albany-Syracuse-Rochester and Buffalo. Frankly what on earth for? How many people today travel between those cities and at what frequency. Any meaningful studies done by disinterested parties? Wouldn’t NY be better off spending $8B (assuming we had it) on something affecting daily commuters anyway or paying down debt?

    The northeast High Speed Rail route – Boston-NY-Philly-Wash DC works successfully because each is s destination in and of itself and millions of people reside in each and move between them regularly. Not so upstate. And anyone who has been to the Rochester Amtrak station knows it is a deplorable and is unseemly and inconvenient in location. The rich and politicians will continue to use corporate and government aircraft anyway.

    Further, the analogies to the Erie Canal are laughable – the canal exists today at the mercy of NY Thruway toll payers who subsidize the rich and their pleasure boats. True, 200 years ago the canal boosted NY economy because NY WAS a key industrial and agricultural state then and there were no roadways nor railways. Not so today.

    If the oppressive fuel taxes and Thruway tolls were removed (as a generation of politicians once said), travel and transport between upstate cities would be far cheaper.

    So instead of helping, this “fast fail rail” proposal will sink us further in debt, enrichen legions of connected lobbyists and firms and leave a tool for politicians to featherbed for decades while NY upstate population continues to shrink.

  2. […] New York State high-speed rail plan stagnant В« Trains For America Jul 23, 2008 … New York State high-speed rail plan stagnant … In New York it seems to be nothing more than bureaucracy. … laughable – the canal exists today at the mercy of NY Thruway toll … […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Top Clicks

  • None
July 2008


%d bloggers like this: